Recognized in the Industry
Badge - AV Preeminent 2020
Badge - Best Attorneys of America
Super Lawyers
Badge - Badge - Avvo Rating 10.0 Top Attorney
Martindale-Hubbell Client Reviewed
Expertise - Best Employment Lawyers in New York City
Avvo Reviews
NYC Bar Association


Churning refers to the excessive account trading for the broker’s own commissions and/or profit, while exercising control over your money.

Churning typically involves a broker frequently buying and selling equities. However, churning can come in other forms. Your broker may buy and sell more expensive products (such as mutual funds), which in effect generates higher commissions, therefore the broker may not need to trade as frequently as they would with general equities. Churning ultimately occurs when your broker aims to generate high commissions for the benefit of himself/herself, rather than for the benefit of you. If you notice frequent trading or excessive fees, it may be an indication that your broker is engaging in churning. You need a New York investment churning law firm like Malecki Law can review your accounts and trading activity at no cost.

Control is exercised in situations when an investor is unable to evaluate recommendations and a judgment is made by the broker on the investor’s behalf, whether or not it was discussed with the investor. Overtrading is essentially the same as churning but refers to excessive trading that is not in line with the customers’ needs and objectives. If you notice frequent trading or excessive fees, your broker may be churning your accounts. A New York investment churning attorney like the lawyers at Malecki Law will review the trading and fees in your account.

You should review documents related to your accounts and ask your broker questions about your accounts. By reviewing documents and statements, you might notice indications of potential churning, such as: unauthorized trading or excessive fees. Unfortunately, doing your due diligence as an investor will not stop your broker from churning your accounts. Therefore, your brokerage firm should have supervisory procedures in place to detect and avoid excessive trading within your accounts. If you notice frequent trading or excessive fees appearing in your account(s), contact Malecki Law’s experienced investment churning lawyers in New York, for a free consultation. It is imperative that the supervisory procedures adequately guide supervisors on how to detect red flags and that the firm adequately trains its supervisors on the next steps to take after they have determined there is a potential churning issue present.

Regulators’ hold brokers and brokerage firms accountable for churning or overtrading in their customers’ accounts. For example, both FINRA and the SEC held broker William Gennity accountable for allegedly churning his clients’ accounts. Specifically, the SEC’s complaint, filed in court, stated that Mr. Gennity “recommended to four customers a pattern of high-cost, in-and-out trading without any reasonable basis to believe that his customers could make a profit.” Further, the SEC found that Mr. Gennity’s misconduct along with his colleague’s misconduct resulted in nearly $700,000 in losses sustained by their customers. Meanwhile, Mr. Gennity made almost $300,000 in fees and commissions. Further, due to its findings, FINRA suspended Mr. Gennity from the industry and ordered him to pay disgorgement, prejudgment interest, and a civil penalty, resulting in a total of $302,483 owed.

Another example, FINRA barred Richard Adams, a former broker at CISC, Inc., for allegedly churning his customers’ accounts. Just under a one-year timeframe, Adams excessively traded and churned two of his customers’ accounts. This resulted in Adams generating almost $60,000 in commissions for himself, meanwhile his customers sustained almost $40,000 in losses. Brad Bennett, FINRA’s Executive Vice President and CEO at the time, highlighted that “FINRA has no tolerance for brokers who place commissions ahead of what is suitable and appropriate for their customers.” An example where a brokerage firm was held accountable, involved NEXT Financial Group. FINRA fined the firm $1,000,000 due to supervisory failures that enabled customers’ accounts to be churned. The churning led to approximately $768,000 in losses within the customers’ accounts. If you notice signs of similar behavior, a New York investment churning law firm like Malecki Law can review your potential case.

Attorney Advertisement. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Testimonials From Former Clients
I highly recommend Jenice and her team at Malecki Law. I had a challenging, and lengthly case. Jenice was professional, very knowledgeable, and a pleasure to work with. She managed to make the process far less stressful during a very difficult time. They care about their clients, and it definitely shows. Mario
Jenice is truly a miracle worker and one of the top securities lawyers. She handled a very difficult case for us, displaying her legal knowledge, intelligence, and savviness throughout the process. I cannot recommend her enough. The quality of work from her team rivals that of corporate law firms. She was always available, extremely professional, and made sure to know all the details of the case. We were very fortunate to have been referred to Jenice and highly recommend her for any securities related legal issues. Nathan A.
An excellent professional who represented us in trial regarding a bank fraud, an unexpected and difficult time. A professional that worked hard, persevering and who stood toe to toe against firms that had a team of excellent lawyers backing them up. Her unflinching determination really stands out, it makes you feel you have someone who really cares about trying to recover what you lost from the people that wronged you. Salomon Levi
It is difficult to thank you in words when gratitude comes from the heart, so I will try to link feelings with writing. It is essential for us to mention your excellence as a professional, your aptitude on legal fields, and your unavoidable persistence. All of these virtues that elevate the profession you exercise in such an admirable way, go hand in hand with your sense of ethics, your human warmth and the transparency in your actions. To sum up, thank you for being a listening ear and for having the right word while transmitting information about the legal process. Having you as our representative during such an adverse situation was a privilege and enough reason for our eternal gratitude. Angeles Aparain
To say that my securities litigation was complex would be a severe understatement. With multiple parties involved and spanning many years, trying to understand the issues was daunting to say the least. Jenice and her team broke down the transactions by segment and by party uncovering every hidden expense. In the end, I was more than happy and could not thank Jenice and her team enough. I would not hesitate to recommend Jenice to anyone. She is highly professional, incredibly knowledgeable, well connected to industry experts, has a tireless work ethic and is so pleasant and easy to communicate with. Five stars for sure! Andrew Loughrane